Tuesday, November 29, 2011

hide the switch and shut the light


Yes, I have been gone for a couple days.

This was not only due to the fact that my son came back home from college for the long weekend. We also, for the first time ever, lost phone and internet service at el Rancho de Drew.

It was probably a good thing, anyway.

But yesterday, I received a copy of the Bulletin for the Center of Children's Books upcoming December review of Stick. A very nice review, in which, according to my editor, the last lines pretty much say it all:


Smith, Andrew Stick. Feiwel, 2011 [304p] ISBN 978-0-312-61341-9 $17.99 Reviewed from galleys R Gr. 9-12
 
Born with only one ear, Stick has grown used to the teasing he endures at school. Worse, however, is the abuse he and his brother endure at home at the hands of both their mother and father, who express their displeasure with savage beatings and by locking their sons in a room bare of all save a cot and a bucket. Stick and Bosten have each other, though, and they each have a close friend—Stick has Emily, and Bosten has Paul, in a relationship that is more than just friendship. It turns out that they also have an aunt, and when they go to her house for their Easter vacation they realize how different home life might be. It’s hard to go back home, especially when they find out that their mother has moved out, leaving them with their father, whom Stick realizes has been sexually abusing Bosten as well as beating them. When Bosten and Paul are caught in a compromising act, Bosten has no choice but to run away, and Stick soon follows, only to run into more trouble than he left at home. This tragic story has at its heart a solid core of brotherly love and loyalty that survives even the worst of situations; it’s those situations that are exceptionally difficult to read about and conceptualize, with their harsh and gritty realism. Aunt Dahlia seems almost too good to be true if readers don’t think too hard about the fact that she hasn’t tried to see the boys for the first sixteen years of their lives; however, it’s enough that she offers a safe haven for them when they finally make their escape. The prose is strong and evocative, lapsing into imagistic poetry at times to reveal the intensity of Stick’s emotions. Readers should be prepared to have their hearts broken by these vulnerable, utterly lovable brothers.


So, thank you for that nice review, BCCB.


10 comments:

Matthew MacNish said...

I'm not sure about a broken heart. Mine was certainly ripped apart a few times, but there were some amazingly kind-hearted characters in there to help me put it back together. There names were Emily, Aunt Dahlia, and ... shit. I forget the truck driver's name.

Otherwise? Another excellent review of a truly great book.

Matthew MacNish said...

Their, not there. Sorry, no coffee yet.

Andrew Smith said...

I have to be so careful when I first start typing in the morning because it takes a good half hour or so for my brain to connect with my fingers.

And maybe it's just me, but I notice a trend among the reviews of Stick, too, in which about half the reviewers (although I haven't seen a bad one yet -- not that I'm asking for one) seem to be struck by the dark, harsh, difficult to deal with realities of the boys' lives; while the other half seems to get the sense of overwhelming hope and joy at the heart of their story.

As the author, I don't count, but I'd fall into the second group, as opposed to the first.

Matthew MacNish said...

There are definitely moments that left me wrapped in a veil of despair, but I think that's the beauty of a great book, or any great story. It makes you laugh, it makes you cry, it makes you tear your hair out. I don't care if a tale has a happy ending or a tragic one, as long as it makes me feel.

That being said, I completely agree. The most powerful piece of this story, for me, was the hope and joy that comes from human relationships. The love the brothers had for each other, and the power of true friendship that Stick got from Emily.

Anyway, back to work for both of us, now. Have a good one, Andrew.

Matthew MacNish said...

And you'll always count as far as I'm concerned.

Jonathon Arntson said...

I'm on the verge of ranting about the word 'dark'. It just keeps popping up! I'm not the ranting type though...it makes me sound unintelligent.

The second group of reviewers would be the ones who actually read the book.

Kristen Pelfrey said...

Hope, renewal, the possibilities of joy. Stick.

Matthew MacNish said...

I'll do enough ranting for both of us, Jon. I embrace my unintelligence.

WV: mentated. Yep, that sums it up.

Adam Russell Stephens said...

Matt, the truck driver's name was Sutton. I really liked him!

Jon, I feel you about "dark". Ridiculous.

Drew, as a fan of your books (you are officially my favorite, your collection worth reading every year), I would say that hope doesn't shine nearly as bright without a measurable sense of despair.

Thanks for providing us with both in your stories. :)

Matthew MacNish said...

Sutton was awesome. Thanks, Adam!